Trending publication
Nutter Bank Report: October 2026
Print PDFHeadlines
- OCC Finalizes First GENIUS Act Rule for Payment Stablecoin Issuer
- Community Bankers Sue OCC Over National Trust Charters for Crypto Firms
- Supreme Court Moves Toward Resolving National Bank Act Preemption Split
- OCC Releases Debanking Report and CFPB Launches Follow-On Investigation
- Other Developments: Digital Assets and Debit Interchange Fees
1. OCC Finalizes First GENIUS Act Rule for Payment Stablecoin Issuers
The OCC has issued a final rule implementing the Guiding and Establishing National Innovation for U.S. Stablecoins Act (GENIUS Act), making it the first federal banking agency to finalize a rule establishing a regulatory framework for permitted payment stablecoin issuers (PPSIs). The final rule released on October 21 establishes standards for PPSI activities, reserve assets, redemption, risk management, capital, audits and reports, custody, and applications. The final rule applies to national banks, federal savings associations, and their subsidiaries, as well as to nonbank entities that seek approval as federal qualified payment stablecoin issuers, foreign payment stablecoin issuers, and certain state qualified payment stablecoin issuers subject to the OCC’s authority. Compared to the OCC’s proposal published in March, the final rule takes a more principles-based approach in several areas. For example, the final rule requires that a PPSI maintain reserve assets that are “sufficiently diverse” to manage credit, liquidity, interest rate, and price risks, subject to two quantitative minimums: at least 5% of reserve assets must be held in demand deposits, insured shares, or Federal Reserve Bank balances, and no more than 40% of reserve assets may be held with a single counterparty, subject to an exception for qualifying custodians. A PPSI generally must redeem payment stablecoins within two business days, and the final rule eliminates the proposal’s automatic extension of that deadline during periods of heavy redemption demand. The final rule will take effect on January 18, 2027. Click for a copy of the final rule.
Nutter Notes: A state-chartered bank that wants to issue payment stablecoins through a subsidiary must apply to its primary federal regulator—the FDIC for a state nonmember bank and the Federal Reserve for a state member bank—and neither agency has finalized its GENIUS Act rules. The FDIC proposed application procedures in December 2025 and substantive requirements for FDIC-supervised PPSIs in April 2026, and the Federal Reserve released its two proposals on September 24, as reported in our September issue. The OCC said it coordinated with the other agencies, but it declined to adopt certain approaches included in the FDIC’s proposal, such as brand-level segregation of reserve assets and required disclosures that FDIC pass-through deposit insurance is not available. So it is possible that the FDIC and Federal Reserve rules may not be identical to the OCC’s rules. The OCC’s final rule also incorporates the GENIUS Act’s prohibition on a PPSI paying interest or yield to holders solely in connection with the holding, use, or retention of a payment stablecoin, but it drops the proposal’s rebuttable presumption that yield paid through affiliate or white-label arrangements violates the prohibition. Instead, the OCC said it will look to the substance of such arrangements and use its anti-evasion authority as needed. How regulators treat third-party yield arrangements remains an important issue for community banks because of the potential for deposits to migrate to stablecoins. At the same time, the requirement that PPSIs hold at least 5% of reserves in demand deposits or similarly liquid assets, together with the final rule’s custody provisions, may create deposit and custody opportunities for banks.
2. Community Bankers Sue OCC Over National Trust Charters for Crypto Firms
The Independent Community Bankers of America (ICBA) has filed a lawsuit challenging the OCC’s authority to charter non-depository, non-fiduciary companies, including cryptocurrency firms, as national trust banks. The complaint filed on October 2 in the U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia asks the court to vacate the OCC’s March 2026 final rule that amended the agency’s chartering regulations to permit a national trust bank to engage in “the operations of a trust company and activities related thereto” rather than only fiduciary activities. The ICBA argues that the National Bank Act authorizes the OCC to charter only three types of national banks—traditional depository banks, bankers’ banks, and national trust banks that exercise fiduciary powers—and that the OCC has effectively created a fourth category of national bank that neither accepts deposits nor exercises fiduciary powers. According to the complaint, the OCC has approved or conditionally approved 21 national trust bank charters during the current administration, at least 13 of which involve cryptocurrency companies. Click for a copy of the complaint.
Nutter Notes: According to the ICBA, a cryptocurrency company with a national trust charter obtains many of the benefits of a national bank charter, including federal preemption of state law, without bearing deposit insurance assessments, Community Reinvestment Act obligations, and other requirements that apply to insured community banks. The complaint alleges that two ICBA member banks, each with less than $2.5 billion in assets, have already lost business to cryptocurrency companies that received conditional national trust charters. The ICBA also raises consumer protection concerns, arguing that customers may assume that a company operating under a “national bank” name is FDIC-insured. The OCC has defended its interpretation by pointing to Congress’s use of the term “trust company,” rather than “fiduciary,” in Section 27(a) of the National Bank Act and to its longstanding practice of permitting national trust banks to conduct certain non-fiduciary activities, such as custody. ICBA has only asked the court to vacate one conditionally approved charter, but a ruling in ICBA’s favor could limit future approvals. The case also could affect the path for nonbank companies that seek to become federal qualified payment stablecoin issuers under the GENIUS Act, which permits uninsured national banks chartered by the OCC to issue payment stablecoins.
3. Supreme Court Moves Toward Resolving National Bank Act Preemption Split
The U.S. Supreme Court has invited the Solicitor General to file briefs expressing the views of the United States in three cases that present a conflict among the federal courts of appeals over whether the National Bank Act preempts state laws requiring national banks to pay interest on mortgage escrow accounts. The Court’s October 5 order covers petitions for review in Cantero v. Bank of America and Flagstar Bank v. Kivett. In its 2024 Cantero decision, the Supreme Court rejected the Second Circuit’s categorical approach to preemption and instructed courts to determine whether a state law prevents or significantly interferes with a national bank’s exercise of its powers. On remand, the Second Circuit held in May that New York’s interest-on-escrow law is preempted, while the First Circuit held in another case that Rhode Island’s similar law is not. In Kivett, the Ninth Circuit held that California’s escrow-interest law is not preempted, relying largely on its pre-Cantero precedent. The order does not mean that the Court has agreed to hear any of the cases. There is no deadline for the Solicitor General’s briefs, so the Court may not decide whether to grant review until well into its 2026–2027 term.
Nutter Notes: The outcome is of particular interest in Massachusetts, which requires the payment of interest on escrow accounts established for the payment of real estate taxes in connection with residential mortgages. As reported in our May issue, the OCC issued a final preemption determination on May 15 concluding that federal law preempts New York’s interest-on-escrow law and substantively equivalent laws of other states, including the Massachusetts law, as applied to national banks and federal savings associations. A coalition of states has challenged the OCC’s escrow rules in a separate lawsuit pending in federal court in Oregon. Massachusetts-chartered banks remain subject to the Massachusetts requirement. Separately, the OCC sent a letter on October 29 to the California Air Resources Board (CARB) urging it to clarify that national banks and federal savings associations are not required to comply with California’s two climate disclosure laws, which require large companies doing business in California to report greenhouse gas emissions and climate-related financial risks. Together with the FDIC’s proposal to extend national bank parity to out-of-state state banks, these developments show that the extent to which state laws apply to federally chartered competitors remains a live competitive issue for state-chartered banks.
4. OCC Releases Debanking Report and CFPB Launches Follow-On Investigation
The OCC has released a report of its findings from a supervisory review of “debanking” practices at the nine largest national banks it supervises. The report released on October 14, entitled Guaranteeing Fair Banking for All Americans, concluded that during a review period from 2020 through September 2025, each of the nine banks maintained reputation risk and industry-specific policies that lacked clear standards and objective, risk-based criteria. According to the OCC, those policies disadvantaged certain customers based on their political, religious, or social views or their lawful business activities. The industries the report identified as subject to restrictions include, among others, oil and gas exploration and production, coal mining and coal-powered plants, firearms and ammunition, detention facilities, tobacco and e-cigarettes, and digital assets. The report also criticized vague account closure letters and stated that SAR confidentiality concerns alone do not account for banks’ poor communication with customers about closures. The report does not identify any violation of law or announce any enforcement action. On the same day, the CFPB announced that it will investigate whether the banks featured in the report, and other institutions under its jurisdiction, complied with federal consumer financial laws. Click for a copy of the report.
Nutter Notes: Although the review focused on the largest national banks, the report signals how examiners and other authorities are likely to evaluate account decisions at banks of all sizes. The OCC said it is considering further rulemaking to prevent discrimination based on political or religious beliefs and to address banks’ use of reputation risk, including reliance on third-party opinions such as advocacy group designations. The OCC also said it will continue to evaluate account termination practices and may issue guidance or regulations on closure notices, and that it may issue guidance to prevent “pretextual” reliance on the Bank Secrecy Act (BSA) to close accounts, including with respect to domestic politically exposed persons. The CFPB has indicated that its investigation will focus on the Equal Credit Opportunity Act, the adverse action notice requirements of the Fair Credit Reporting Act, and the prohibition on unfair, deceptive, or abusive acts or practices. The CFPB’s supervisory authority extends only to banks with more than $10 billion in assets, but community banks should consider reviewing their policies on account opening, account closure, and customer or industry restrictions to confirm that decisions are based on documented, individualized, and risk-based criteria.
5. Other Developments: Digital Assets and Debit Interchange Fees
- FinCEN Withdraws Two Digital Asset Proposals
FinCEN on October 5 withdrew two proposed rules related to convertible virtual currency (CVC). The first, proposed in December 2020, would have imposed recordkeeping, verification, and reporting requirements on certain CVC transactions involving unhosted wallets. The second, proposed in October 2023, would have imposed a special measure identifying CVC mixing as a class of transactions of primary money laundering concern. Click for FinCEN’s announcement.
Nutter Notes: The withdrawals took effect on October 6. Banks that facilitate digital asset transactions for customers remain subject to existing BSA requirements, including suspicious activity reporting and customer due diligence. Banks considering digital asset or stablecoin activities also should monitor the proposed BSA/AML and sanctions rules for PPSIs that FinCEN and OFAC issued in April, as well as the OCC’s forthcoming BSA rulemaking under the GENIUS Act.
- Eighth Circuit Strikes Down Federal Reserve’s Debit Card Interchange Fee Cap
The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit has affirmed a federal district court judgment vacating the 21-cent per-transaction cap on debit card interchange fees in the Federal Reserve’s Regulation II. In a unanimous decision issued on October 26 in Corner Post, Inc. v. Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System, the court held that the Durbin Amendment to the Electronic Fund Transfer Act permits the Federal Reserve to consider only the incremental cost of authorizing, clearing, or settling a particular debit card transaction, which the court interpreted to mean the marginal cost of an additional transaction. The court concluded that the Federal Reserve improperly included fixed costs and other costs that are not specific to a particular transaction when it set the cap in 2011. The court remanded the matter to the Federal Reserve to develop a fee structure consistent with the statute, but it did not set a replacement cap. The decision will not take effect until the court issues its mandate after the period for seeking rehearing, so the current cap remains in effect for now. Click for a copy of the decision.
Nutter Notes: Regulation II’s interchange fee cap applies only to debit card issuers that, together with their affiliates, have $10 billion or more in assets, so most community banks are exempt from the cap. However, a lower cap for large issuers could put downward pressure on the interchange fees that exempt community banks receive if payment networks narrow the gap between regulated and exempt rates. In a separate challenge to Regulation II, a federal district court in Kentucky upheld the rule, and an appeal of that decision was argued before the Sixth Circuit on October 22. If the Sixth Circuit upholds Regulation II, the resulting split between the circuits would increase the likelihood of Supreme Court review.
Nutter Bank Report
Nutter Bank Report is a monthly electronic publication of the Banking and Financial Services Group of the law firm of Nutter McClennen & Fish LLP. Chambers and Partners, the international law firm rating service, after interviewing our clients and our peers in the profession, has ranked Nutter’s Banking and Financial Services practice among the top banking practices in the nation. Visit the U.S. rankings at Chambers.com. The Nutter Bank Report is edited by Matthew D. Hanaghan. Assistance in the preparation of this issue was provided by Daniel W. Hartman and Heather F. Merton. The information in this publication is not legal advice. For further information, contact:
|
Matthew D. Hanaghan Tel: (617) 439-2583 |
Daniel W. Hartman |
Michael K. Krebs Tel: (617) 439-2288 |
Kate Henry |
This update is for information purposes only and should not be construed as legal advice on any specific facts or circumstances. Under the rules of the Supreme Judicial Court of Massachusetts, this material may be considered as advertising.








